Blog Archives

Nine Months After


It was a beautiful day today, like spring is already here. Birds were atwitter, trees are showing signs of life again, spring plants have started to blossom. Inside the house, a new life, a baby girl, is taking hold, growing stronger every day. It was a beautiful day too, nine months ago. Summer was in full swing, the neighborhood awash with life in full flow. But inside the house, a life was ending, a baby cat, each breath drawn laboriously, a body tired and slowly filling up with the unexcreted toxins. Shanthala had said that day, “It’s a beautiful day to die”. No, it was too beautiful a day to die. I wish he had raged against the dying light. But then, he came with no agendas but to live his time here, no stakes for immortality or such vainglorious ideas. He lived, loved and then went.

After nine months, it was again a Tuesday on the 26th. I relived those days nine months ago, all over again. I remembered that fateful Saturday midnight when I took rushed him to the vet after he vomited for the fifth time that day. Shanthala had started crying saying that she was really worried about him. I had not worried then. How exhausting that Sunday was as we watched him double up as if in sudden pain, hiding under the bed, driven by instinct to hide when vulnerable. And that blessed relief on Sunday night when he jumped on the bed to sleep with me. Little did I know that that was his last jump onto the bed. And then the horrible Monday when a phone call in the morning and a phone call around 3 PM revealed that it was all over. I sat in the corner where he breathed his last at that fateful time in the afternoon. I took Maya and sat by his graveside for a while.

They say a cat has nine lives. Where did he lose his nine, we wondered then. The first was probably when he survived whatever kidney problem he suffered as a kitten. The next was when he came to our house when he was abandoned by the neighbors, trusting us to take care of him. The third was when we brought him back from the animal shelter, where we had given him up because we were uncertain if we could care for him. The fourth was when we discovered that he had a kidney problem when he went for a teeth cleaning procedure and we put him on a special diet to protect his handicapped kidneys. The fifth and sixth were when he was attacked by the landlord’s dogs at the place we stayed in. The seventh was when Shanthala rescued him from the streets of India where he had escaped to, the spirit of adventure and curiosity ever so strong in him. But where did the eighth and ninth go ? How could we have lost him ? The grief of his death is still so strong, Shanthala and I cry remembering him even now.

The presence of Maya has not lessened his loss. I thought that immersed in the daily rituals of raising a newborn, I’d forget about him for a few days. But I suffered no respite. Maybe I guard his loss as some people guard their jewels, protecting it from being forgotten, unwilling to let the memories dim, to let time do its thing.

As many nights endure
Without a moon or star
So will we endure
When one is gone and far – Anjani & Leonard Cohen

Maya is Born


Maya Aditi was born to us on Feb 10. She weighed 8lbs 4oz and was 21 inches long. She is an adventure seven long, sometimes frustrating, sometimes hopeful, but always heartbreaking years. As a dear friend wrote to us, “One day you will know how eagerly we have all waited for
your arrival”. Coming so close on the heels of our hardest loss, the death of Kitty, I feel the circle of life complete. I also felt his loss more acutely than ever. I took her to where his remains are scattered and asked him to watch over her. I don’t believe in those things, yet I took some comfort from that ritual. Someday little Maya, we’ll tell you his story and yours.

On the day you were born
the Earth turmed, the Moon pulled
the Sun flared, and, then, with a push,
you slipped out of the dark quiet
where suddenly you could hear…
…a circle of people singing with voices familiar and clear

And as they held you close
they whispered into your open, curving ear,
“We’re so glad you’ve come!” – Debra Frasier

Winter Came Early

Winter came early this time. It just took a little time before the trees caught on, before the leaves began to turn, to then fall. It just took a little time for the sun to realize, to come up a little later and go down a little sooner. It just took a little time before the birds caught on, before they fled the cold for the warm southern skies. It just took a little time for the wind to realize, to turn the strong evening eastern summer wind to a gentler but colder winter breeze. Winter came early this time, back around the end of June, when Kitty died and took the warmth with him.

Its eight months now. Yet the ghost of him still sits at the top of the step, waiting for me to feed him. The ghost of him lays beside me at night, waiting for me to hug him. Waits by the door every morning, waiting for me to let him out into the world. Lies in the bright strip of sunlight in the living room, luxuriating in the warmth, showing me how wonderful life is. Wanders the neighboorhood, waiting for me to call him in. Calls to me at night, waking me from my sleep, my hand automatically seeking his warm body next to mine. Its eight months now and yet I can’t get my head wrapped around the idea that he’s dead, returned to the dust whence he came from.

From July till September, I dreaded the arrival of each Tuesday, the day he died. From October, I dreaded the coming of the twenty sixth of each month, another way that my brain has filed away as the day he died. I’d have a sense of relief that the day passed with nothing untoward happening. Shanthala had wanted to bury Kitty in our yard instead of burying only his ashes. I was afraid to. I was certain that I’d desecrate his grave in my grief some day, searching for some sign that he was once with us. Then as the first week or two went by, my brain would start the countdown, getting ready for the ritual of writing an entry, laying a wreath, sitting by the graveside for a little while.

I tiptoe around his death, around my knowledge of his death. To confront it directly is still terrifying in some incomprehensible way. Shanthala wanted to steam clean the carpets before the baby arrived. So we rented a machine from Home Depot and cleaned all the carpets. Late that night she said, “Where he died, there was a little drop of his blood. Now that’s gone too.” I had forgotten about that. I got up, wide awake now, to see if it was true. That little drop was gone, our diligent scrubbing getting rid of the accumulation of yesterdays. But the past lives on inside my head, our heads, where we visit it every now and then, greeting it with silence and tears, and occasionally with a smile.

Shanthala had said a few years back, when her grandmother had died, that her grandmother had come in her dreams and told her that she was OK. Shanthala had been able to make peace with her death after that. On our wedding anniversary this year, Kitty came in my dreams for the first time since he died. I don’t know where it was, maybe it was our house in Sunnyvale. He walked in and meowed loudly, like he did when he wanted some food or attention. I asked him what he wanted and he meowed loudly again and I followed him. That was it. I woke up a few minutes later. Last week, I dreamed about him again, two days in a row. The first night we’re all together and I’m playing with him, when he starts coughing out blood. The second night, I call to Shanthala that Kitty is back as I see a golden colored tabby walk into the house. Then I go closer to the cat and see that it is not him.

The winter months were sleepy times for him. He slept more than usual since he couldn’t go out into the rain. Some nights he’d snuggle under the sheets with me, the cold driving him there. Those were innocent times, happy times.

The ghost of you walks right through my head
Sleepwalks at the foot of my bed
Sends old shivers over my skin
Love like that, won’t let go
It’s got some kind of a mind of its own
I can’t break out and I can’t break in — Richard Thompson

Fare Thee Well, My Nightingale


Kitty had the most mellifluous voice I’ve heard in a cat. It complemented his loving, gentle nature and drop dead good looks. Shanthala and I used to say that he was a nightingale. He was a very vocal cat with an astonishing range of vocalizations. I had no idea that cats had such a range of vocal sounds and so many of them sounded very much like responses to questions that I asked him.

Of his sounds, the first thing that I heard on waking up in the morning were his purrs and his quick, soft meows. He’d wait for the first signs of my waking up. If I as much as fluttered my eyes, he’d immediately utter his quick, soft meow, more like a “Good, you’re awake, I’m hungry”. If I didn’t wake by a certain time, he’d start patting my face with his paws, uttering soft meows. After I woke up and went to feed him, he’d utter another quick meow, sounding more like a “Yummy”, his purring would increase in amplitude and he’d crouch down to feed.

His quick meows were also used as gentle reminders such as when he was waiting by the door, waiting for one of us to open it for him or to announce that he was back and needed to be let in. If we asked him if he was hungry as we walked up to his eating place, his response sounded close enough to a “yeah!”. He also had a grunt or meow that sounded like a “no”. Some days, he’d be sitting by the front door, surveying the world as it went by. I’d open the door and ask him if he wanted to come in. He’d say “Uh!”, a short sound that sounded very much like a “not yet”. If we were going out somewhere, I’d say that he had to come in, in a slightly more pleading voice and he’d get up, meow a complaint and walk in.

It is speculated that many of the vocalizations of a cat are reserved for communicating with their human slaves. A Cornell study found that cats utter meows in a way that elicits the response they want from their human companion. In other words, cats train their owners and not the other way around and I’m living proof of that. However not all cats are as vocal, with the Siamese cats as renowed for their chatter as the Persians are for their silence.

Kitty could also control the amplitude of his meows based on the amplitude of my voice. We’d be in bed, he sleeping in the crook of my arm as I fondled him or cuddled with him. He’d be purring loudly. If Shanthala was asleep already, I’d whisper “Kitty, do you know I love you ?” or “You know you’re a real sweetheart Kitty, don’t you ?”. He’d whisper back a meow, as softly as I had asked the question, a meow that sounded like “Of course!”, his eyes just half-open. Sometimes, he’d be asleep and I’d wake in the middle of the night and look at him for a while. He’d wake up too with me and go back to sleep immediately once he realized that it was not time to be fed yet. I’d whisper sometimes, “Kitty, are you asleep ?” and he’d give me a silent meow.

The other sound that he made frequently was a melancholic “Aaauuu” that increased in intensity and pitch over time. This was the sound reserved for when he was agitated by the presence of another cat right outside, in his territory, and he was inside and couldn’t do anything about it. I realized this much later. The first time he made that sound, I thought that something was wrong and rushed to see if he was OK. When I did that a few times, he realized that he could get my attention quickly with that sound. One evening, we were in the kitchen and he was perched by the living room bay window. He made that sound and as I rushed out, I saw his head peeking out from behind the drapes looking at the kitchen door with intensely curious eyes, as if he was testing to see if I’d come immediately. When he saw me come, he tried ducking back behind the drapes, but he was a little slow. He meowed in irritation and jumped out and walked away.

His purr was of course our favorite sound. He purred so loudly that Shanthala would say “Kitty, we need to fit you with a silencer”. He’d only purr louder. When we were in bed at night and he was ready to sleep, his purring would stop for an instant and we’d hear a deep sigh and all would be silent. He was off chasing mice in dreamland. Many times, he’d purr, meow and eat at the same time, producing a unique sound that my brain now tries hard to not forget. Many times, he’d also softly snore, a sound so pleasant and human like, that I felt overwhelmed with love for him.

He’d also meow in irritation or frustration when he didn’t get what he wanted. Shanthala’s mom who isn’t so crazy about animals at home, was even less crazy about a cat. One night, when she was visiting us, I was working late in the night and Kitty was perched in my lap, half asleep. She was sitting nearby and could see what was going on. As the clock advanced to midnight and I showed no signs of stirring, Kitty woke up and meowed, an indication that it was time to go sleep. I said, “Soon, Kitty, soon”. A few minutes later, he meowed again with a slightly more irritated tone. I ignored him and continued working. I ignored a few more of the irritated meows. He then jumped on my keyboard, uttered a really loud meow and slapped my hand in irritation. Shanthala’s mom was surprised to see so much emotion in a cat and that was the turning point of her affections for him. She told everyone who’d listen about Kitty now and she’d usually start with that story.

When we were living in India about two years ago, one evening we went to our owner’s house, downstairs, and had a pleasant evening chatting with them. When we opened our front door upon returning, we heard a really loud wailing or screeching sound, one that terrified me. I had not heard Kitty making that sound before. I then saw a feral cat rush out from our bedroom, leap to the living room window and slip away. I rushed in to find Kitty hiding under the bed from where he refused to come out till much later. I later read that this sound is called caterwauling and is produced when the cat is fighting with another cat and the other cat won’t back down. I never heard Kitty produce that sound again.

Shanthala would joke that Kitty and I could have a conversation in which we understood each other. One such conversation happened one evening when Shanthala was on call. I was going up to take bath and Kitty was coming down. As we passed each other, I said “Kitty, what’s the plan for the day ?”. He stopped and half turning grunted a sound which sounded like “I don’t know”. I said “I’m going up to take bath. Do you to come with me ?”. He looked up at me, seemed to think for a few seconds and uttered a “yes” meow, turned around and climbed back the stairs with me and sat by the bathtub as I had a shower.

The last sound he produced before he died was hiss at the doctor who had come to euthanize him. She had pricked and prodded him the previous day in an attempt to get his kidneys to recover and he was mad at her. That morning, as he lay by the door, in a torpor with all the toxins accumulating in his body, the sun came out. I asked him “Kitty, do you want to come lie in the sun ?” and opened the drapes, letting the sunlight stream through. He meowed a soft “yes” and lifting himself with effort, crawled to the sun and collapsed there.

It’s been six months since those last sounds. My brain struggles against itself to remember those sounds. I remember many of them, but fear how accurate they are. How I wish we could hear our nightingale one more time.

Fare thee well my nightingale
I lived but to be near you
Though you are singing somewhere still
I can no longer hear you – Leonard Cohen & Anjani

The End, Five Months On


“In my beginning is my end”, wrote T.S. Eliot. From the moment he walked into our lives nine years ago, his ending was certain. That was the only thing that was certain. Yet, I continue to resist this specific ending. I continue to mourn, five months to the day, his death. Depression has a particular form, a particular way of expression, I thought. It is sitting still and staring at the ceiling, immobile, it is the refusal to get out of bed, it is the inability to go about the business of living. When thoughts of him rush to fill every empty space in my brain, when with each breath I inhale, his memories are once again relived, I wonder if I I’m depressed. Active grief lasted about two months and this despair, this sense of loss, has been my companion since then.

We traveled to Kauai recently. With Shanthala in her advanced state of pregnancy, we stuck to little walks on the beach, short drives to nearby places and lots of time hanging out in the cottage, reading books and surfing the web. We took with us the trilogy of the adventures of Norton, the cat that went to Paris. I had a fervent wish to have Kitty travel with us, but he seemed discontent to roam and prefered the warmth of the hearth. We had a cat sitter visit him every day at home to feed him, pet him and clean his litter. We had hired a non-professional cat sitter who came highly recommended to us. She always mentioned how sweet Kitty was and how he loved to be petted. Once when she was unable to cat sit, she recommended her cat sitter to us, a professional. This lady left notes about her day with Kitty. Here are some entries:

“I have brought some fresh catnip for Kitty cat. He spends the whole time lying on it, rolling around on it and meowing at me as I sit on the couch watching him.”

“Today, Kitty cat followed me upstairs when I put down food. I just had to laugh; there I sat on the floor cross-legged next to his bowl. He ate, he rubbed against me for petting, I brushed him, he purred. If I stopped the attention, he looked at me like “More petting please”. Too funny. I’ve never taken care of a cat that has this habit.”

“He is so cute when he lays on that next-to-top step and sticks his head through the bars looking down at you”

“He loves laying on that rug in the living room and pulling himself around and being petted.”

He always knew when we would be traveling and he’d get very upset. Initially, he’d get very anxious too, probably from being abandoned by his previous owners. Later he just got upset. He wouldn’t let us touch him or pet him. When we were leaving, he’d hide under the bed and refuse to come out. When we returned, he’d show his anger by sitting in the same room as us, but at a little distance from us, with his back to us, complaining his meows every now and then. Attempts to touch him then were discouraged. He’d typically get over his anger in twenty minutes or so and then no amount of petting would be sufficient. He’d rub himself against us and be around me all the time. Unlike Norton and many of the other cats that I’ve heard about, he never once messed up the house to show his displeasure at being left behind, just the twenty minutes of his “back to us” routine.

This time, I took his collar with me to Kauai. No quarantines for you now, I said to myself. We arrived at our cottage around 3 PM and within a few minutes, a cat, a black and white tabby, stood at the back screen door, meowing very determinedly to be let in. We let him in and he wandered the cottage, exploring the place as if he was checking that we had not messed up the place yet. He talked as much as Kitty did, though his voice was not as mellifluous. He let us pet him and soon vanished. We didn’t see him again till the day we were leaving. At 8:30 in the morning, he showed up again, this time at the front door. He let us pet him again before he went away. My brain cried out to ascribe meaning to these random events.

Norton suffered kidney failure too, but it was caught early enough that they put him on some saline drip twice a week to let him live long enough to die of cancer. Shanthala cried as she wondered why our vet had not prescribed the saline drip for Kitty. She has a colleague who has a cat with kidney failure but leading a normal life, thanks to the daily saline drip. I don’t know why our vet didn’t do this. It seems too late to matter now.

Kitty died again two weeks ago when I received a postcard from the vet, addressed to him, saying that it was time for his yearly shots. I have yet to call the vet and tell him that he’s dead.

Thus Nature spake — The work was done –
How soon my Lucy’s race was run!
She died, and left to me
This heath, this calm and quiet scene;
The memory of what has been,
And never more will be. – William Wordsworth